Should You Refinance Your Student Loans? Welcome to my blog on refinancing student loans. If you’re like many post-college grads, you’ve likely been paying down student debt for years now. With interest rates rising, your loans may feel impossible to pay off. Refinancing could help lower your payments and save you thousands in the long run. But is refinancing the right choice? In this post, I’ll break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision.
What is Student Loan Refinancing?
To understand whether refinancing makes sense, let’s start with the basics. Student loan refinancing involves taking out a new private loan to pay off existing federal or private student loans. The goal is to secure a lower interest rate, reducing the overall cost of repayment.
When you refinance, your existing loans are paid in full with funds from the new private refinanced loan. This new loan then becomes your sole student debt repayment obligation going forward. You’ll have a single monthly payment at the new (hopefully lower) interest rate for the full refinanced amount.
Who Can Refinance Their Loans?
To be eligible for refinancing, you’ll typically need to meet the following criteria:
– Have good credit– Most lenders require a minimum credit score, usually around 670, to qualify for the lowest rates.
– Have stable income– Lenders will want proof you earn enough to afford the new monthly payments. A paystub, W-2, or tax returns may be requested.
– Be employed or have work history – Refinancing lenders prefer borrowers with steady employment to assess repayment ability.
– Have qualified student loan debt– Both federal and private loans can be refinanced, as long as they’re in repayment and not in default.
Meeting the above eligibility rules helps lenders feel confident you’ll repay the refinanced loan on time each month. Paying your existing loans on time also strengthens your approval odds.
Understanding Interest Rates
Interest rates are a major factor when deciding whether refinancing makes sense. With federal student loans, rates are generally fixed for the life of the loan. But private refinanced loans may have variable or fixed rates. Let’s look at each option:
Fixed Rates – With a fixed rate loan, your interest level stays the same for the entire repayment term, usually 10-20 years. This provides predictable monthly payments.
Variable Rates – Variable rates fluctuate up or down based on a financial index, resetting periodically. While rates may be lower initially, they carry more risk as they can increase over time.
When weighing refinancing offers, closely compare both the starting interest rate and any potential for future rate changes. It’s also wise to research recent rate trends for the index a variable loan would track. Fixed rates eliminate uncertainty, though you may pay a somewhat higher starting rate.
Weighing Refinancing Pros and Cons
Now that we understand the basics, let’s dig deeper into factors to consider when deciding whether refinancing makes financial sense for your individual situation:
Potential Pros:
– Lower interest rates can dramatically reduce repayment costs over time. Even dropping 1-2% could save thousands.
– Faster payoff with lower monthly fees frees up more cashflow each month.
– Streamlined repayment consolidating multiple loans into one may simplify budgeting.
– No prepayment penalties allows paying extra to pare down principal.
Potential Cons:
– Loss of federal benefits like flexible repayment options and forgiveness if you refinance from direct federal loans.
– Higher rates for some borrowers if your credit has declined since taking initial loans.
– Less flexibility than federal student loans with refinancing. You can’t pause payments like with forbearance or deferment.
– Private loan risks variable rates or inability to discharge debt through bankruptcy are concerns.
Weighing these pros and cons relative to your goals, finances, and risk tolerance will help decide if refinancing fits your situation or not. Let’s dive into some scenarios.
When Refinancing Makes Sense
There are a few scenarios where refinancing student loans clearly makes financial sense and can deliver significant savings:
You Have Excellent Credit
The top interest rates are generally reserved for borrowers with credit scores of 720 or higher. Even half a point lower means saving thousands in the long run.
Rates Have Declined Significantly
If rates have fallen 1-2% or more since your initial student loans, refinancing locks in a lower payment for years. This has benefitted many over the past decade.
You Have Private Loans at High Rates
Those with costly private loans at 7-10% will see huge savings refinancing into much lower fixed rates under 5%. The payment reduction is massive.
You Want a Shorter Repayment Term
Some refinances offer 5 or 7 year terms, getting debt paid faster. This works well for individuals able to afford higher monthly payments.
In these cases and others like high current loan balances, refinancing is often a no-brainer to substantially cut repayment costs over the life of the loans. Let’s proceed to some less clear-cut scenarios.
When Refinancing May Not Be Worth It
While refinancing can work well for many, it may not provide benefits or could even increase costs for others:
You Have Federally-Backed Loans
Giving up options like income-driven repayment, forgiveness programs, and disruptions protections may not be worth a small rate drop for some.
Rates Have Recently Risen
If you refinanced in the last year or two before increases, you may already have a low rate that isn’t worth sacrificing protections to match today.
Your Credit Has Declined
Without pristine credit, you may not qualify for the advertised refinance rates, limiting potential savings. Rates may exceed your federal loans.
A Short Repayment Window Remains
With just a year or two left at the current rate, the minimal savings may not offset private refinance loan risks for such a brief term.
Variable Rates Concern You
Borrowers worried about uncertain fluctuations long-term may prefer the reliability of federal fixed rates over private variable offers.
In borderline cases, running the detailed numbers out to full repayment is prudent before pulling the refinancing trigger. Let’s look at calculating potential savings next.
Calculating Potential Refinancing Savings
The only way to know for certain if refinancing will save you money is to crunch the numbers for your specific situation. Here are the steps:
1. Gather loan details – amounts, rates, monthly payments on all current loans
2. Get refinance offers – ask for rates on different terms from multiple lenders
3. Compare rates and terms – calculate monthly and total interest between options
4. Project full repayment – amortization tables show exact savings over 5/10/15+ years
5. Account for fees – most refinances charge 1-2% origination fees paid upfront
6. Consider tax implications – interest paid on refinanced loans may not be deductible
7. Check break-even point – how long until total savings outweigh upfront fees? 1-2 years is desirable.
Run these side-by-side comparisons to ensure any offer will truly save you money over both the short and long haul. Savings projections of just $50-100 a month may not be worthwhile after factoring in all associated costs.
Always evaluate multiple refinance quotes before committing. Lenders compete on rates, so shopping around preserves the most potential savings opportunity.
Choosing a Refinancing Lender
Once you’ve determined refinancing makes financial sense for your loans, it’s time to pick the right lender partner. Shop offers from the top student loan refinancing companies:
– Earnest
– SoFi
– Laurel Road
– Splash Financial
– Citizens Bank
– Navient
– ELFI
– CommonBond
When evaluating offers, consider:
– Interest rates and available terms
– Borrower benefits like career support
– Online customer experience and reviews
– Variable rate adjustability options
– Loan sizes/eligibility
– Prepayment flexibility
– Creditor reliability and reputation
Read online reviews to learn real borrowers’ experiences with application and servicing standards. Poor customer service can negate savings if issues later arise.
Choose a lender offering you the lowest rate, best terms, and highest confidence managing your debt repayment for years to come based on proven track record.
Final Refinancing Checklist
To maximize your chances of savings through refinancing:
– Gather and analyze your detailed loan information
– Allow lenders to “soft pull” your credit to receive multiple rate quotes
– Vet multiple quality refinancing options side-by-side including fees
– Project full repayment costs and break-even analysis over years
– Consider repayment preferences and eligibility for protections
– Verify rates are locked in for 30